Should I Sell My Art?

This page contains affiliate links. If you choose to purchase after clicking a link, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.


Should I sell my crochet?

 Is Selling Crochet for You? 

Selling art is a unique profession. There is a constant internal struggle between caring for the art enough to hook pieces of your soul into it and then being able to turn around and sell it. Beyond the logistics of pricing, choosing your audience, and keeping an inventory, there is a very emotional side to selling crochet items, or any art for that matter. It is something you have to decide for yourself. Are you ready to sell your art?

I love my job. I feel like I’m doing what God has guided me to do because it makes me happy, and He keeps telling me this is where I am supposed to be, which is a pretty awesome feeling.

However, it does not mean that everyone should assume selling crochet items is always rewarding and fun. It’s work. And no matter how much you love something, once you start making money doing it, it becomes work. (A dreaded 4-letter word if I ever heard one.)

These are things that I have discovered in the last few years of running my business, and they are sometimes a struggle for me. I have to ask myself these things over and over.

What do you like to make?

 This one sounds simple, but I want to go deeper than just the surface “anything!” that most people respond to. 
  • What is your favorite thing to make? 
  • What could you make 20 of and not get bored? 100 of? 
  • What makes you squeal with delight when it is done and dance around the room with it? (Can you tell I do this with stuffed animals?)

THAT is what you should be making. Not whatever is popular. Not what sells best at craft fairs. Not what you can crank out fastest. 

Make the thing you love. 

When I got started, I had a lot of people tell me, “When you do something you enjoy for work, you no longer really enjoy it.” I was determined that that didn’t have to be the case. I started out taking custom orders, saying I was willing to make anything for anybody. That got old fast. Why? Because I was making little girl hoods, slippers, and a lot of character hats! These are cute, but do not make me sing and dance.

So I changed my attitude. I do occasional “out there” custom orders for my close friends but beyond that, I make things based on my own patterns and offer custom orders on things I already know and love.

If you “chase the dollar” by making whatever anyone will commission, you will be end up making things that you don’t care about, and art is all about caring! If you don’t care, your work will suffer and so will your creative muse. 

Make things that make you feel happy to make and proud to sell.

Do you have time to crochet for strangers?

 You love to crochet. You love it enough that you consider yourself good at it, and friends probably compliment you on your work and want you to make things for them. Up until now, you have always had a few projects going of things for you or family members.
So, if you have a stack of WIPs (works in progress) beside your desk chair, do you really have time to start crocheting for strangers?

As soon as I started my business and the orders started coming in, I realized that the projects first stuffed in a drawer were those intended for me or my sons.

I hate to admit it, but my oldest son is still waiting on a Tepig (Pokemon) that I told him I would make years ago and haven’t gotten to because I’m always working on an item that has a deadline. When you make things for other people, they expect it in a reasonable time frame, which means you end up making the orders first and your personal projects second.

My small way around this is to always have a “car project” going that is not work related. It is usually the only thing I have going that is not work-related. I take it with me everywhere and work on it waiting for school to let out or waiting for appointments to start. It gets about an hour of work a week, if I’m lucky.

But the truth is that none of the projects on or around my work space are for me or my family.

Are you willing to give up the generous nature of making a blanket for every new baby in your bible study? Are you willing to sit on that amazing shrug pattern for six months before you get a chance to make it for yourself?

3. Can you really let go of the items?

When you make something to sell, it gets purchased. You get money, they get the thing — whether it be an adorable beanie for their son/daughter or an afghan into which you have poured 40 hours.

When you hand over that item and get the money, you HAVE to let it go. For your own sanity, you have to remember that that item is, literally, not yours to worry about any longer.

I hear a lot of crochet artists who make something for someone, even sell things to people, and then don’t like where they end up (often a thrift store) or don’t like how they are being treated (“It is just dusty up in a closet!”).

Someone could buy your 25-hour afghan and use it to catch oil drips under their car. Heartbreaking? Yes. But that is the risk you take when selling items.

The item isn’t yours anymore. You sold it.

Can you deal with that?

I have to ask myself that a few times a year, especially when I put a LOT of work into something, like a custom stuffed animal, and then put it in a box on its way to Canada, knowing I will never see it again and probably never hear from the owner.

I can be proud of my work, take the money, and hand it over. That was the choice I made. I chose to sell it.

I listed it, took payment for it, and made it for someone else. Now it’s theirs.

(See my post about letting go of stuffed animals, and you’ll see why this is a hard one for me, every dang day.)

If this makes you cry uncontrollably (and even your significant other can’t calm you down), then you may want to rethink selling your items.

 Don’t Expect the Gracious Thank You

 Have you ever bought a shirt you really loved at Kohl’s (or anywhere) and then wrote to the manufacturer a letter about how much you loved it and that it was a life-changing purchase and you would keep it forever and ever? 
Me neither.
Don’t expect your customers to hug you and thank you for the heirloom gift they will treasure. Expect them to be happy with a smooth transaction and be on their way.
Do not sell your crochet with the intent of getting pats on the back for your skills. Craft fairs are a great place for pats on the back. You can get lots of strokes to your ego from passers by just telling you how wonderful your work is.
This will rarely happen from an Etsy order. In fact, less than 10% of people even leave a review, and a lot of those are just the number of stars.
The compliment you get on a regular basis is simply that they chose you as their crochet artist.

Try to remember that with every payment a person thinks that your work is worth them giving over their hard-earned money so that they can have a piece of it.

That is the biggest compliment you can get.

Yarn on,


(Visited 481 times, 1 visits today)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *